Landing a quick first response from a prospective real estate client gets your foot in the door. However, two common roadblocks can easily stall a promising lead: not having all the facts on hand straight away, and radio silence after your initial response. If left unhandled, either situation can see a warm buyer or tenant slip straight into a competitor's hands.
According to a Prop Data poll, the biggest group of property practitioners (42.3%) reply to new enquiries within five to 29 minutes. Hitting that window with a complete answer is tough if you're between appointments or need to verify specific property facts first. Rather than leaving the client hanging until you have every detail, try this:
Acknowledge the enquiry: A quick message lets prospective clients know they've been heard and that someone is looking into their question. Vanessa Champion, Sales and Letting Manager at Maxprop Umhlanga, points out: “Clients don’t necessarily expect an immediate answer to every question, but they do appreciate knowing that their enquiry has been received and that someone will get back to them.”
Have a holding message ready: Save a short response on your phone for times when you're in a meeting, viewing, or otherwise unavailable. Champion suggests: "Thank you for your enquiry – I am currently unable to give you my full attention, but the moment I am free, I will respond." You can also use automated acknowledgements, provided they still feel personal rather than overly scripted.
Give them a timeframe for your next update: You can take your response a step further by letting prospective clients know when they can expect to hear from you, whether that's later in the day or the following morning. Johan Meyer, Principal and Licensee at Seeff Pinelands, explains that his team uses pre-written replies and automated templates to acknowledge enquiries. He adds: “At worst, all clients should receive either a personal call or written response by the next morning at the latest, especially if the enquiry comes in during the evening.”
Be specific about what you need to check: Rather than giving a vague response, let the client know which details you're verifying and, where possible, answer the parts of their question you can. Check the relevant documents or speak to the right person before confirming details such as pet policies, property availability, or additional costs. It's better to take a little longer than to give someone inaccurate information.
Keep track of outstanding enquiries: Log questions that still need answers, assign them to the relevant person, and set reminders for promised callbacks. A shared CRM can help ensure that enquiries don't get lost, particularly when several practitioners are handling incoming messages.
Close the loop once you have an answer: Get back to the client when promised, even if you're still waiting on information. Once you've confirmed the details, answer their original question clearly and explain any conditions or next steps. If something has changed or is taking longer than expected, let them know rather than leaving them wondering.
You’ve replied to the enquiry, answered their questions, and suggested a next step. Then … nothing. When a prospective client goes quiet, knowing when and how to follow up can make all the difference.
Qualify leads early: Before investing too much time in follow-ups, establish whether the person is a genuine prospect. Someone enquiring about a property may simply be gathering information, may not be ready to buy or rent, or may not meet the property's requirements. Ask a few direct questions about their needs, budget, timeframe, and readiness to make a decision. This helps you prioritise promising enquiries and tailor your follow-ups accordingly.
Make your follow-up personal and specific: Rather than sending a generic “just checking in” message, refer to the original enquiry and the property they asked about. Keep it short, friendly, and easy to respond to. You could suggest a viewing time or ask whether they'd like to arrange a quick call.
Champion makes a point of following up first thing in the morning. Her suggested message is: “Hi, it's Vanessa again. If you are still interested in the property you enquired about yesterday (and I insert the link again), please let me know when you are available for a quick chat to make sure this particular property suits your needs.”
Give them a reason to respond: Don't make every follow-up a request for an update. Share something relevant to their original enquiry, such as a new listing that matches their requirements, an article that answers a question they raised, or a useful update about the property. Each interaction should offer something of value rather than simply reminding them that you're waiting for an answer.
Try another communication channel: If your first reply was an email that went unanswered, a brief WhatsApp message or phone call might work better. Pay attention to how the prospective client prefers to communicate, rather than repeatedly using a channel that hasn't worked.
Be persistent but know when to stop: A lack of response doesn't always mean someone isn't interested. They may be busy, distracted, or still considering their options.
Champion believes in following up until she has a clearer idea of where things stand. As she explains: “Life is so busy these days, and people sometimes don’t have the time to reply to everything.” After trying to call and getting no response for about a week, she sends one final message:
`
“Hi, it’s me again! I have tried to connect with you regarding your enquiry about the property at … but we haven’t seemed to manage to chat. Just give me a thumbs-up if you want me to keep you on my radar, or a thumbs down if you have found your perfect property.”
If they decline, she thanks them and moves on. The important thing is to respect their decision and avoid making follow-ups feel like pressure.
Keep track of enquiries and follow-up activity: A CRM helps you see who has been contacted, when you last followed up, and which prospects are still waiting to respond. You can set reminders for future check-ins and record the client's requirements so you can contact them when a suitable listing becomes available.
Meyer explains that his agency uses its CRM to keep in touch with prospective buyers whenever a new listing becomes available. In an area with a shortage of stock, some buyers are already in their system and can be contacted before a property is even advertised.
A note on marketing permissions: Keep follow-ups relevant to the original enquiry. A prospect's silence doesn't automatically give you permission to add them to a newsletter, property alert list, or marketing campaign. Under POPIA, unsolicited electronic direct marketing generally requires consent, with a limited exception for qualifying existing customers. Make sure you understand the requirements before adding anyone to a marketing list.